Becta home page

This Question is Possibly Answered

1 "correct" answer available (4 pts) 2 "helpful" answers available (2 pts)
13 Replies Last post: 28-Oct-2008 10:07 by RogerBroadie  
Click to view Andyt's profile Becta person 16 posts since
05-Feb-2008

18-Apr-2008 12:16

What benefits can learning platforms bring?


Much discussion on learning platforms has focussed on technical issues or procurement that, whilst very important, can sometimes leave people more confused and disengaged from the process. In February a group a schools who have been using learning platforms for a little while came together to share the benefits for learning, teaching & management that they are getting from theis use of technology. A report of the outcomes from this event is available in the documents area.

The outcomes and benefits have not been verified or analysed in any great detail but it would be very useful to hear what community members have to say about the headlines. Questions that you may wish to consider could include:

Do you recognise some of theoutcomes and benefits?

Are you interested in knowing more?

Do the essential steps to success make sense?

If you attended the event you may wish to add to the conversation.


Click to view Pilgram's profile Level 2 28 posts since
06-Feb-2008
1. 16-Jun-2008 21:58 in response to: Andyt
Re: What benefits can learning platforms bring?
Benefits

Learning Platforms are part of the key that will unlock 21st century learning. They provide the relatively safe and secure environment that will promote collaboration towards shared goals. They are only part of the combination of technologies that will do this however.


Learning Opportunities can be created on the Learning Platform which allow activities to be started at school and then continued when a learner wishes- either at home or at school. These opportunities can then be stored for use with following classes in the same way that content in IWB files can be stored. The opportunities are much greater due to the sharing of resouces amongst, and occasionally beyond, the school community. In a media rich world they allow carefully chosen resources based in different media to be shared amongst the learners. Through active discussion forums different aspects of a theme can be unpicked.


Learners can become authors beyond their teachers, to the class, to the school and to the wider world. Before this year, I doubt whether more than a handful of people read the work of children in my class. Now both they and I know it has been read by thousands.

Click to view Tideway's profile Level 1 1 posts since
19-Jun-2008
2. 22-Jun-2008 12:15 in response to: Andyt
Re: What benefits can learning platforms bring?

We have been using a Learning Platform in Tideway School for over 4 years.

In June 2008 we ran a small pilot research project with 8 Year 10 students, building delivery of a Unit of work within ICT into the learning platform - students could complete lessons in school time or from home or from wherever they had access to the Internet - ICT lessons took place Period 1 on a Monday - students who completed the online lesson could chose to register from Period 2 onwards - assessment took place through a formal online exam at the end of the Unit (results were higher than the school average and there were some interesting comments from students about their experience of flexible learning with a learning platform).

The pilot is being extended in November/December 2008 when all Year 11 students will be given the opportunity of studying a Spreadsheet unit of work online. The results of this will have an impact on school policy in relation ot the delivery of subject content and assessment online.

I have posted information about this and other projects on our school website at www.learningplatforms.info

Jim

Click to view joelhjosephson's profile Level 1 1 posts since
19-Jun-2008
3. 23-Jun-2008 12:14 in response to: Andyt
Re: What benefits can learning platforms bring?
In my opinion, the learning platform itself is relatively transparent to the educational outcome. A learning platform is merely a tool, it has features that can be used either easily, or with difficulty, depending on the platform and the knowledge of the user. There are already a multiplicity of platforms from 'Open source' to propriatory systems.

The heart of the matter is the content that is delivered over a platform. Does it have teaching value, does it use all the resources of the platform that enable the content to expand the bounderies of the classroom. It is possible to have the most sophisticated platform but if the content delivered is poor, then the platform could be considered a failure and will not be beneficial.

Almost 5 years ago I founded the Kindersite Project and at the time I wrote a short piece on the use of digital content. I asked, how we are going to evaluate and analyze the efficacy of digital content for learning, not the delivery system.

I would be very happy to be pointed to any studies that have considered this aspect of the use of ICT in the classroom. I have the results of one study that used the Kindersite content within a study, the results are available through the Kindersite.

Joel Josephson
Kindersite Project
http://www.kindersite.org
Click to view Robin's profile Becta person 4 posts since
07-Feb-2008
Joel does raise a key issue - much hinges on the quality and fitness for purpose of digital content and supporting resources as opposed to the preferred delivery mechanism.

Getting to grips with these issues can be a bit of a minefield as it is such a subjective area - so much is dependent on the context, desired learning outcomes and environment in which any digital learning resource is deployed. What works for one person may not produce the same impact as someone else's engagement with the materials.

There are principles which can be followed and applied to help teachers become more discerning in their choice and use of DLRs. Becta's Quality principles for digital learning resources can be found by following the link. This is not a 'silver bullet' but does at least provide a sound framework from which to move forward. One final document which is also useful as well as really informative is Becta's recent publication Choosing and using digital resources: A guide for school leaders which, includes amongst a range of resources an step-by-step interactive PDF.

Hope that helps...
Click to view garyclawson's profile Level 2 34 posts since
02-Jun-2008
6. 29-Aug-2008 16:11 in response to: Robin
Re: What benefits can learning platforms bring?

It's good to see some recognition that a key benefit of LPs is to carry digital resources to the students and use the facilities of an LP to create activity around these resources. These resources can be created\sourced\ or purchased.

Many teachers new to LPs will want resources already in there to enable them to exploit LP collaboration facilities. Many teachers will want to engage the student with a good use of multimedia and find that creating their own materials is time consuming and their own limitations may leave the student with a an LP that is simply carrying dry text with some pictures.

So where do the Digital Resources come from apart from the teachers who create them on their own platform? Purchased.......maybe.........but very few suppliers provide true LP resources that can exploit the tracking and assessment. Even fewer licence in a way in which the teacher can integrate the resources and not have any fear that when the school can't pay the annual licence their own work collapses without the 'rented' content.

One last thing, don't LPs now prevent sharing of resources with schools developing their own content but sharing with another school or another Local Authority now included the issue of how to do so easily. Resources in LPs are not openly available as they sit behind licenced applications, we've a great danger of having LPs that give great potential for collaboration between pupils and teachers............but not much in the way of digital materials to collaborate about?

Click to view marshal's profile Level 2 20 posts since
10-Dec-2007
+So where do the Digital Resources come from apart from the teachers who
create them on their own platform? Purchased.......maybe.........but
very few suppliers provide true LP resources that can exploit the
+tracking and assessment.++


I have to be a bit careful here because I am a man of many hats and there are many sensitive toes out there. BUT: There is a huge issue here for developers - especially those in the primary phase. They have gone from a stuation of creating stuff to work with one unpredictable system (with no integrated tracking/reporting of course) to having to produce stuff to work on (at least) 10 different systems whose only common standard is the rather un-cuddley SCORM. Not only does SCORM not really lend itself to all the kewel and spiffy collaborative learning we (OK, I) would love to see going on in LPs, but it means each product needs to be tested (at least) 10 times - some SCORMs are more equal then others (even though they shouldn't be). This development comes at a time when developers are experiencing a massive drop in sales with the end of ELCs and are having difficulty funding new products of any kind.


I'll get me coat,


Marshal

Click to view garyclawson's profile Level 2 34 posts since
02-Jun-2008
8. 30-Aug-2008 23:00 in response to: marshal
Re: What benefits can learning platforms bring?

Other countries have better strategies and don't have policy makers that have been decisive over platforms but clearly don't understand how to develop a digital resource supply.

eLCs have left behind a commercial market that was artificially inflated with no management of the quality of digital resources or their technical standards. The good stuff largely lost amongst the garbage and those suppliers with the biggest investment in marketing being the most successful. As for standards of development, they were never a condition of the COL branding, a brand that is a more a kitemark of poor quality than it is good.

Other countries are much smarter, they motivate the take-up of learning platforms in schools by creating National Repositories of resources. By setting a single set of standards they also encourage developers to produce to this one standard, establishing stability in the way in which resources are produced and an easy way for any supplier to have a profile in that market without major investments in marketing. A level playing field. Repositories such as these make resources easy to find and more importantly......enable easy exchange between learning platforms. If you read BECTAs Harnessing Technology Strategy there is simply a hope that there is a market response and repositories, resources and tools to create them will emerge. They probably will........to many different standards, creating even more barriers to sharing.

We are way behind many other countries, not in our strategic knowledge but in the IMPLEMENTATION of that strategic thinking.

Click to view Pilgram's profile Level 2 28 posts since
06-Feb-2008
9. 08-Sep-2008 22:48 in response to: Andyt
Re: What benefits can learning platforms bring?

Is the main point of Learning Platforms to deliver content? Recent contributions seem to indicate that many people think this is the case. However, many of the successful Web2.0 applications are social networking sites where the content is created by the users and the site is the framework. If we are to engage learners with the learning platform then we need to utilise the best points of the media rich resources available with the ability to create, edit and control their own work.

Learning Platforms are after all just another resource. We need to start with the pedagogy not the technology. What is the pedagogy for 21st century learning with the resources at our, and our learners, disposal? What does this mean for the organisation of learning? How is this work to be assessed?

Pilgram

Click to view garyclawson's profile Level 2 34 posts since
02-Jun-2008
10. 08-Sep-2008 23:31 in response to: Pilgram
Re: What benefits can learning platforms bring?

I don't think that the main purpose of Learning Platforms is to deliver content, but neither is the main purpose to simply have tools to create and collaborate. But I do believe that the best way to establish a Learning Platform is by having curriculum relevant content to enable the teacher to establish collaboration.

The Web 2.0 argument occurs regularly - why don't our learners learn, in school, the way they learn out of school, with similar use of social technologies. But school is a very different place than home and the use of technology is very different in school than it is at home. Schools are also large institutions and for every teacher comfortable with technology there are 5 that are not, for every teacher capable of exploiting Learning Platforms there are 5 that aren't. Maybe their first use of a Learning Platform by a teacher will be to use an interesting video clip or a series of photos, or a animation to spark on-line discussion and if that content is already there to build upon maybe more teachers will be confident to go further?

There is another issue, Learning Platforms are not like Web 2.0 social technologies they have inbuilt barriers called licences. Platforms will encourage sharing across individual institutions but not between them.

Click to view AlexJones's profile Level 1 4 posts since
24-Jun-2008

It's not a bad thing going through all the potential and possible benefits a learning platform might bring. It is certainly a good thing for schools to share their views of what benefits they have gained from a learning platform.

Also useful would be some reliable research that transcends the anecdotal and provides a very solid basis for arguing with teachers that investing their energy in a learning platform will be helpful.

Does anyone know of any?

Click to view TonyParkin's profile Level 1 4 posts since
18-Jun-2008
The "reliable research that transcends the anecdotal" is perhaps a grey area - as widescale surveys designed to ramp up data counts can frequently replace the anecdotal with the superficial, and be equally unreliable.
However the ICT Register (www.ict-register.net) has been undertaking some research into what schools that have familarity in the use of Learning Platforms have identified as working for them. The work has been carried out by former primary headteacher David Broadfield, who has himself had extensive experience of working with learning platforms, and who has been working with informed schools identified via the ICT Register. Currently an interim report is available, but more will be added in the coming months.
I suspect that it will by gathering together such research that a clearer picture will emerge as to what truly makes a difference in this area to schools. We also hope to pursue further work with schools who have experiences from more than one learning platform, so that we are not merely identifying "the best of the devil-they-know" but starting to tunnel into what really matters to the learning.
Click to view RogerBroadie's profile Level 2 14 posts since
14-Jul-2008

Alex and all,

You will have very great difficulty finding 'research that transcends the anecdotal'. Evaluation of the impact of learning platforms is very difficult, because though the platfom is tool and catalyst, a huge amount of the impact will come from pupil & teacher attitude changes, caused not only by the way the platform changes work processes but also by all the other things a schools does to create the teaching/learning changes they see as desirable.

There is also the issue that the impact from ICT is very diverse. When we analysed 'value-add from ICT' in E.E.P. discussions (http://www.eep-edu.org - innovations service) we identified 11 different ways ICT can add value to learning/teaching. The way I would have used a learning platform when teaching in Skipton would have been completely different to how I would have used it in the Sheffield school I taught in. Another view of this diversity is available in work Naace did, http://www.future-learning.net/.

I can also offer you a white paper done in Nov06 but still very relevant, which has loads of verbatim quotes from SLT in a dozen schools, on imperatives, drivers and challenges in implementing learning platforms, http://www.frogtrade.com/index.phtml?d=289212. Again see the diversity of drivers.

What I am essentially saying is that a school has to first ask what benefits they need and want, then to ask how a learning platform might bring those benefits, which then leads to realisation of what features of the platform are going to really matter - is it content, or scaffolding and tracking learning activity, or collaborative functionality, or ability for pupils to be create/personaise areas in the platform for curriculum and extra curriculum purposes.

And a final suggestion - the only way to evaluate impact is to compare before and after processes; look at how particular teaching/learning activities happen in the absence of a digital environment, and then compare this with the amount and quality of teaching/learning that happens when a learning platform is used effectively. You have to start the journey yourself to get the research that really matters to you.

Roger.